For a long time, history was a
part of literature – a collection of verbal accounts, of stories, at
times fascinating. It has been enriched by visual materials in the form of
portraits, at first painted and drawn, then reproduced in print and,
eventually, replaced by still photographs. Then came "motion
pictures" in the form of silent and, later of speaking films. Here we
shall consider three ways of "enriching words by visual images":
illustrated books on the history of psychology, slides and videos,
reminding readers (and ourselves) of the impressive series of filmed
dialogues with notable contributors to psychology, produced in the 1960s
by R. I. Evans. Filmed dialogues with notable contributors to psychology.
Books
Most books on the history of
psychology, including textbooks, are skimpy on illustrations or lack them
altogether. In the early 1990s, large illustrated works on history of
psychology appeared in print both in the United States (Popplestone &
McPherson, 1992) and in Germany (Luck & Miller, Eds., 1993, 374 pp.).
Most of the contributors to the latter volume are German, Austrian, or
German Swiss. In addition to a handful of foreign contributors, lightly
scattered throughout the text, the section on "regional
developments" (pp. 203 – 241) contains contributions of individuals
from Brazil, Canada, Czech Republic, Germany (2), Hungary, Peru, Spain,
and USA (3).
A substantially enlarged edition
(636 pp.) of the German volume appeared in the USA (Bringmann, Lück,
Miller & Early, Eds., 1997). It is richly illustrated by portraits of
individual psychologists, their carricatures, photographs of groups, title
pages of numerous books and of journals, apparatus, tests and projective
techniques, diagrams and tables, graphs and figures, studies, laboratories
and their floor plans, tests and testing facilities, buildings, letters,
research notes, as well as academic certificates and records.
These are valuable and
interesting supplements of the text.
Slides
For use in classroom and for
illustrating lectures in general, several sets of slides have been made
available, varying both in content and quantity. Thus a set of 345 slides,
supplemented by 51 pages of text, accompanies a volume on illustrated
history of psychology in America (Popplestone & McPherson, 1992).
Recently a set of 34 slides,
illustrating internacional history of psychological testing, was assembled
by Peter van Drunen, director of The Archives of Dutch Psychology (Grote
Kruisstraat 2/1, P. O. Box 1710, 9701BS Groningen, The Netherlands). The
accomapying brochure, dated November 1997, was prepared in cooperation
with Donald van Tol.
The brochure lists the slides
under four categories:
1. Early History, from the
physiognomy of Johann Caspar Lavater (1741- 1801) and Franz Joseph Gall´s
(1758-1828) phrenology through Cesare Lombroso´s criminal anthropology
(1887) and P. Broca´s craniometry to the "anthropometric
laboratory" of Sir Francis Galton, installed in London in 1884.
2. Intelligence Testing,
beginning with Alfred Binet (1857-1911) through the Army alfa and Army
beta scales used in America in the first world war to D.Wechsler and the
controversial volume, The Bell Curve (1994), written by Richard Herrnstein
and Charles Murray.
3. Personnell Select and
Psychotechnics, stressing the use of apparatus and illustrated by the
testing of French pilots (cca 1916), the first aptitude-testing train car
of Saxony´s railway company (cca 1921), and selecting workers in the
psychotechnical laboratory of the Philips company in Eindhoven (The
Netherlands, cca 1930). A driving simulator was used by the Dutch Postal
Services (cca 1935).
4. Clinical Testing, focused on
projective techniques and including the portrait of Herman Rorschach
(1884-1922), the father of the "ink-blot test" of 1921. The
section refers also to Henry Murray´s (1935) Thematic apperception test
and Lipot Szondi´s test (1947).
Selectively, the slides can be
used in a variety of contexts, including introductions to psychology and
applied psychology, in addition to courses on the history of psychology.
Slides lack two components that
were provided by the speaking films and the modern videos, readily
displayed on television screens: Action and verbal content.
Videos
The reviewer was introduced to
this approach to the history of psychology at a symposium entitled
"Centenary of Mira y Lopez: A Psychologist between two
Continents", chaired by Prof. Helio Carpintero (Universidad
Complutense, Madrid, Spain) and held in Sao Paulo, Brazil, in the context
of the XXVI Interamerican Congress of Psychology. The impressive video was
presented by the symposium´s chairman and its presentation was followed
by a lively discussion.
The Mira y Lopez video is the
first of the three videos that have been produced in Spain so far.
Additional five videos are in the pipeline and others are likely to be
added. Each of them deals with one of the outstanding Spanish
psychologists.
Who are the producers and who are
the customers? The organization that generates the Spanish videos, at the
rate of about one unit per year, is the Center for the Design and
Production of Audiovisual Media, a unit of the Vicepresidency for
Methodology, the Media and Technology of a unique Spanish academic
institution – the National University for Education at a Distance. The
idea was conceived by two Madrid historians of psychology, Helio
Carpintero and Enrique Lafuente. So far three videos were released,
accompanied by informative booklets.
The available videos deal with
the following individuals and topics:
Video 1: Francisco Giner de los
Rios and the Institute of Free Instruction in Spanish psychology (Lafuente
& Carpintero, no date).
Video 2: Luis Simarro and the
beginnings of scientific psychology in Spain (Lafuente and Carpintero,
1995).
Video 5: Emilio Mira y Lopez: A
Spanish psychologist between two continents (Carpintero & Lafuente,
1994).
We shall note some common
features of the accompanying booklets:
1) Each provides essential
biographical information about its "hero".
2) Data and illustrative material
available in the literature are supplemented by information obtained
through intensive archival research, thus significantly contributing to
the documentary value of the series.
3) Extensive "Chronological
tables" cover events in a given individual´s life, developments in
psychology, and historical events.
Importantly, the videos
themselves portray the lives and activities of each individual not in
isolation but against the social, political, intellectual and scientific
back-ground.
The running time of the tapes is
36 minutes for Giner de los Rios, 31 for Simarro, and 25 for Mira y Lopez.
As na approach to the teaching of
the history of psychology, the Spanish video project is impressive and, in
its totality, unique. It is to be hoped that it will be a stimulus for
historians of psychology in other countries.
The videotapes and the booklets
are distributed by Libreria de la UNED, Bravo Murillo 38, Madrid, Spain.
Bibliographical References
Bringmann,
W. G.; Luck, H. E.; Miller, R. e Early, Ch. E. (Eds.) (1997). A pictorial
history of psychology. Chicago: Quintessence.
Carpintero,
H. e Lafuente, E. (n.d.). Guia didática: Francisco Giner de los
Rios. Madrid: Universidad Nacional de Educacion a Distancia.
Carpintero,
H. e Lafuente, E. (1994). Guia didactica: Emilio Mira y Lopez.
Madrid: Universidad Nacional de Educacion a Distancia.
Drunen,
P. van e Tol, D. van. (1997). A visual history of psychological
testing. Groningen: The Archives of Dutch Psychology.
Evans,
R. I. (1969). Filmed dialogues with notable contributors to psychology. Psychological
Reports, 23, 159-164.
Lafuente,
E. e Carpintero, H. (1995). Guia didactica: Luis Simarro. Madrid:
Universidad Nacional de Educación a Distancia.
Lück,
H. e Miller, R. (1993). Illustrierte Geschchte der Psychologie. Munich:
Quintessenz.
Popplestone,
J. A. e McPherson, M. W. (1992). An illustrated history of American
psychology. Dubuque, IA: Brown & Benchmark.
Note regarding the author
Josef Brožek is a retired Professor of Psychology and Researcher at Lehigh University, Bethlehem, U.S.A. He was born in 1913, in the city of Melnik, in Bohemia, and became a North American citizen in 1945. He received
his PhD at Charles University, in Prague, Czech Republic. Since 1936, he assumed teaching positions at important European and North American universities, such as the M.I.T.
(Massachusetts Institute of Technology), where he worked from 1980 to 1981. Among his numerous published works, particular attention has been given to those regarding Behaviour in Undernourishment and History of Psychology. He is one of the pioneers in the research field of History of Modern Psychology.
Contacts: Lehigh University, Department of Psychology, 27 Memorial Drive West, Bethlehem, Pa.,
USA, 18015.